I had a quick visit with Armstrong & Getty this morning to discuss the UHC CEO murder, America’s reaction thereto, why so much of the ire on this topic is off base, Obamacare’s medical loss ratio mandate, the Medicare cost shift, and some super simple advice on purchasing insurance products.
Since 2009, I’ve been on air with Jack and Joe well over 100 times. It's always an honor to be on their show.
Exorbitant Hospital Pricing in the U.S. Undermines Morale, Employee Compensation, and Employer Profits — It Must Stop
As the sun dipped below the horizon on a brisk spring
evening, a young mother crouched behind home plate, catching for her daughter. Already showing signs of a future softball
superstar, Gisele unleashed a wicked rising fastball. It clipped the edge of the glove and smashed
into her mother’s face, cracking bone and pushing her nose sharply to the left.
In a display of savage tenacity, Mom wiped the blood away, grimly
reset her nose with a crackling snap, and resumed her catching duties for the
evening. Despite her efforts, the
misshapen lump and the nose’s noticeable leftward slant gave her the hardened
appearance of a seasoned mob enforcer.
Doctors told her she’d almost certainly require surgery but
wanted to let the swelling subside and see how her breathing progressed before
they intervened.
Months later, she couldn’t breathe through her left nostril;
she wanted her beak fixed. Luckily, she found herself on a Mahoney Group plan
backed with Reference-Based Pricing and Cash-Pay options at recognized centers
of excellence.
So no, UHC and Adventist, her plan isn’t going to pay $74,000.
Nor will she pay the $58,000 sought by Cigna and El Camino Hospital.
Not going to pay $73,000 either, Western Health and John Muir.
And we say nay nay to the $73,000 Santa Rosa Memorial wants from EVERY commercial payer. (Hat tip to the late, great John Pinette.)
She’ll pass on the $51,000 Stanford and Blue Shield want.
And UCSF and Aetna can only dream about that $69,000 they lustily crave.
At 140% of Medicare, we will pay $7,811 for this surgery. If circumstances such as geography, timing, or
specialized surgeons demand a higher price, we can negotiate. But that is seldom required. In this case, Gisele’s Mom is getting her
nose fixed up for a voluntary cash price of $7,750.
Plus, since Mom agreed to use the cash-steerage option, her
employer is paying 100% of the cost of the procedure and waving all
deductibles and coinsurance.
And from now on, Mom’s going to wear a catcher’s mask.
With over 15 years of
teaching benefits and human resources at the university level, coupled
with exclusive experience in working alongside C-Suite executives to
implement and manage highly efficient benefit plans, I have a crucial
piece of advice for any HR professional looking to be seen, appreciated,
and impactful in their career.
The insurance industry is massive, powerful, and 100% designed to win every single time. Commissions on some items you buy are more than 50%. YOU DON'T NEED ALL OF THAT!
When engaging in Reference-Based Pricing on your employer health plan, there are several different ways you can pay that repricer: per employee per month, a percentage of billed charges, a percentage of savings, or a flat fee. Which one or ones are best, and why?
What are health insurer overrides? What do they mean for employers and employees? How do you know where they are most likely to lurk?
I've uncovered a new nugget of insider intel on this one - insurance brokerages are turning the volume up to 11 on their insatiable longing for these hidden payments.
Today, with
the greatest sense of professional pride I’ve ever had, I announce that I’ve
come home to where I belong and where I will finish my career.I’ve been in benefits full-time for 22 years
(32 years if you add part-time work after high school, during college, and in law
school).Since 2002, I forged
unimaginably rewarding and life-changing bonds with clients, teammates, and
vendor partners.
Unfortunately,
also during that time, the underlying businesses housing my team’s efforts were
sold. Each time, this corporate
shuffling resulted in a larger, more bureaucratic, and an entity less aligned
with our values. Liberty Benefit sold to
BB&T, which then merged with Sun Trust to form Truist and rebrand and
reshape their hundreds of insurance agencies as McGriff.
Culturally,
philosophically, and at the deepest levels of intrinsic motivation, these
entities became further and further removed from my mission and purpose:
To provide businesses with the most cost-effective, innovative,
and high-quality employee benefit plans while simultaneously helping them
manage their risk and compliance and treating every dollar as though it is the
last an employee can afford to pay for care.
I wrote that
in 2004, and it has been my North Star ever since. Regrettably, often the larger an organization
grows, the further it removes itself from such a mission. Stock prices, shareholder demands, quarterly
growth, EBITA, and a pursuit of new sales at all costs are not conducive to
making sure each client continues to receive exactly what it needs – even if
they were last year’s sale.
So, after
watching changes that did not align with my business values take over and then
seeing private equity swoop in, 2023 became a year of endless introspection,
prayer, and discussion with my wife. Something had to change.
With a heart
full of pride, energy, and vigor, I announce today that I am the newest member
of the Mahoney Group, a privately held and employee-owned organization with no
interest in Wall Street’s stock prices or private equity. As I restart my career at 50 years old, I am
now brimming with joy.
I used to
think I wanted to retire between 50 and 55.
Now, I chuckle at that assessment. The kids are grown and on their own. My youthful exuberance to hunt, fish, bike,
and backpack is still there, but only as a hobby—not an all-consuming addiction.
No. I know
where I can make the biggest impact, and that is by providing businesses with
the most cost-effective, innovative, and high-quality employee benefit plans
while simultaneously helping them manage their risk and compliance and treating
every dollar as though it is the last one an employee can afford to pay for
care.
In so doing,
my new teammates at the Mahoney Group and I will fight doggedly to ensure you
are not being taken advantage of by a deeply flawed healthcare delivery
system.
Ever imagine healthcare could feel like the Wild West? Welcome to the untamed lands of Reference-Based Pricing (RBP), the sizzling frontier where a select few employers unleash radical savings while giving the traditional PPO system a stiff arm.
Unveil a world where only 3-4% of employers dare to tread, but where jaw-dropping 30-40% savings rain like gold and concierge-level service is the sheriff in town.
Curious about RBP's magic? This isn't just healthcare. It's "Health-FAIR!" Here, employers "price-match" medical costs against benchmark prices, slicing their claims in half compared to big insurers.
Projections say employer healthcare costs will shoot up another 7-9% in 2024. Yet Medicare Part D Premiums are projected to decrease by 1.8%. All major insurers participate in both markets. The lesson? Employers with private insurance are subsidizing Medicare. But hold your horses. With RBP, brace yourself for a 0-2% trend that turns the tables on traditional care.
Jump into this roller-coaster ride of a podcast with your guide through this maze, joined by two titans of the trade—Omar Arif of ClaimDOC & Scott Schnaidt of HST. They've both cracked the code, each in their unique ways, and the results? Nothing short of spellbinding.
🎯 What's on Tap:
The gears and levers behind RBP
Navigating the legal minefields
Secrets from Third-Party Administrators (TPAs)
RBP's performance across the geographical board
The art of handling balance bill claims
Litigation: When & How Often
Co-fiduciaries: The real deal or just smoke and mirrors?
Show Me the Money: Their pay structure dissected
Year-end Report Cards: The Good, the Bad, and the Profitable
And just when you think it couldn’t get any cooler—did one of these guys actually play pro baseball in a global tourney, while the other rocked the stage with NIRVANA? 🎸⚾
Lock in your earbuds. Prepare for a mind-bending journey. You’re entering "The Repricers"—Healthcare’s Final Frontier! 🌌🛸
I spent one morning this week chatting with Armstrong and Getty regarding the news that the federal government will finally begin negotiating the price of drugs. 10 of them. Two and a half years from now.
Your health insurance costs and premiums have skyrocketed compared to the rate of inflation since Obamacare passed. Meanwhile, insurance carrier stock prices have grown by 1900% in the same timeframe.
"They're making unimaginable amounts of money... off of you." -Joe Getty
Craig Gottwals, aka "Craig the Healthcare Guru,” talks about that and more in a new episode of A&G's Extra Large Podcast.
Listen to the Armstrong & Getty Extra Large Podcasts featuring Craig.